soft moon fantasy - an imaginary Gordon/DrJOnes collaboration
by ursula

Comment:
Awesome! Great technique, only wish it had been a real model but other than that, perfect. 10

Liberty & Justice, Great Briton Edition.
by marbo

Comment:
It´s a bit to clean, to static for my taste or even to "perfect". No little droplets inbetween the bigger droplets and IMO that is what makes the original shot work so well. Not bad though, way better than what I came up with, gave it a 7.

A Splash of a Different Color
by Kathryn8

Comment:
Not as sharp or well focused as the original but it´s a lovely shot. I am not sure it would have been better but one thing I like about the original is that it´s not quite so "up close" but this works also.

Pianissimo Encore [Soft Focus, Yellow Ribbon]
by dipaulk

Comment:
In my opinion better than the original, but the fact that I know it´s copied drags it down a notch so I "only" gave it a 9. Hope you do well.

Meet the Griswolds (Tacky Holiday Decorations)
by Prof_Fate

Comment:
As far as I can see this is the same house that won in "tacky holiday decorations" but that shot has so much more quality. The sharpness and colours and exposure are better in the original and also the composition being a bit wider with no cars also makes that a better shot.

Anyway, not bad, but not good either so I gave it a 5. Merry christmas!

Homage to Jacko & Rackat
by hughletheren

Comment:
Awesome, great tribute and by itself a flawless shot, could be in any catalouge of commercial I could imagine. 10

Broken Love
by Gauti

Comment:
Sorry to see you sacrifice a filter for this but this photo works. However, the original is better composed and in my personal opinion a red colour of the filter would have worked better since most people (myself included) associate love with red. I gave it a 7.

if he ain't broken, don't sit
by Donald

Comment:
I don´t know what to say really... The quality of the shot is pretty bad, poor focus (or even no focus) bad colours and poor contrast makes it look very flat. Also I don´t see how this is supposedly "broken"? I gave it a 1, hope you do better next time.

Broken
by Dim7

Comment:
I really don´t see how this fits the challenge, I don´t see anything broken in the picture, just a lot of snow.

Snowden Park
by dixonp1

Comment:
Love this shot, great colours and framing. I probably would have given it a 10 but IMO this doesn´t truly meet the challenge as I can´t make out any landmark except for that sign so I gave it a 9.