Wieringer Barge WR6
by Azrifel

Comment:
Hmm, wierd but I like the odd colour sceme in this shot, normally I am very anal and want them neutral but this colour sceme works in this shot. Got a solid 7 from me.

Moonlight Sonata
by kirbic

Comment:
Nice but the landscape is a bit too dark for my taste but I have done this so I know you have to stay within 2 minutes to "freeze" the stars but still, that is my opinion. Still very nice though, don´t get me wrong, I would have been proud to have taken this myself.

Olivia Grace
by train

Comment:
A bit too flat in the contrast area for my taste, but a lovely shot of a lovely girl.

Under the Old Oak Tree
by Studio18

Comment:
Very mystical, almost like a painting, I really like it but it´s just a tad to dark for my taste. Also, I think I would have liked this better if there was actually something underneath the tree as your title suggest, like a couple kissing or something like that but still one of the better shots in the challenge, got an 8 from me.

Summer fun
by GreenGiant

Comment:
Nice work, nothing that is really blowing me away though, maybe I am a bit spoiled, I am comparing this to the shot that beat me in "sports II" but still pretty good, I would have been glad to capture this. Feel that I might have liked this a bit better if the face would have been as dominant as the ass of the person surfing :P

Turning point
by garlic

Comment:
Not really crazy about the sky, wish it was more dark and dramatic instead of light cyan as it is now but the rest of the shot is pretty good even though it´s a little bit cramped on the composition. Nicely exposed and I get a sense of story behind this shot, going to come back after the challenge to see what you wrote in "photographers comments", hope you took the time to write the story behind this :)

Leaving Las Vegas
by JoelHSmith

Comment:
Not bad as concert shows go but not really that good either, good enough for most newspapers though I think, nice job on the lighting. However, I really wish I could see more of her face, this shot IMHO needs more power or emotion and here I think the face would have been the key. 6 from me.

Deep in Utah Country
by mycelium

Comment:
Nice, love that it´s B/W and the tones are awesome, very contrasty and crisp. Does the location justice and makes me wanna go there.

Saucy Sun Rise
by fitmpdnsthtr

Comment:
Nice shot, that is, everything but the sun and the area around the sun, it just looks bad, so bad I went from giving it a 6 to a 5. Nicely composed though.

London Nights
by angela_packard

Comment:
Argh, sorry but the light up in the right corner with the flare is really killing the shot for me, I find it almost impossible to look beyond it at the rest of the photo, it´s really is working as a black hole as far as my attention to this photo goes. Not trying to offend, just wanted to explain why I gave it a low score.