Encounter
by MichaelC

Comment:
Nice, but I think I would have liked it better if just the glass was in focus and he was totally out of focus or the exact other way around, "half & half" like it is now isn´t really working for me. 4 from me this time but I like your thinking with this shot and I suggest you keep at this, you are on to something.

Bottle cap with a twist
by bjorninn

Comment:
Love the shallow DOF but I think you went just a tad overboard with it, just think this shot were stronger if the red green top were in better focus.

containment
by fatLouie

Comment:
Bet you are getting a few "DNMC" votes as I can imagine some people not seeing the glass for the conveyor stairs but I am not one of those, think it fits the challenge well and I hope you are doing well. Love the composition and coloring in this!

Glass Marble
by fotogal

Comment:
Excellent work in regards of lighting and the tonal range in this shot, well done. Not as fond of the composition, a bit too centered for my taste but nothing that is hurting the shot. 7 from me.

Midnight Oil
by outland

Comment:
Sorry but 95% of this frame is just too dark for my taste, and yes, my screen is calibrated. Would suggest a shadow/highlight adjustment for next time.

Broken Glass (with a twist)
by smcc

Comment:
Cute title, should have taken two of those and put "II" in the title too, that would have been even funnier :)

Shallow
by _fred_

Comment:
I don´t know why but it bothers me that you have all that space to the left and then don´t include the whole coin in the frame, just don´t think it "looks right" sort of.

behind the window
by m4rea

Comment:
Lol! So cute!

Orbs - redux
by Tom_Robbrecht

Comment:
I love the simplicity in this shot, just so elequently not trying to be more than it is and that is what makes it work. I am not too fond of the composition though, would have had the "horizon" lower int he frame and the orbs more in the lower right corner if I had taken this, I gave this an 7.

Eco
by Techo

Comment:
Excellent work, not a thing I would change about it except for if it were edited in advanced editing, I would have made the yellow metal part of the bulb yellow again and not had it with such a strong green hue but in basic editing, this is perfect. Still "only" gave it an 8, not really a wow image for me but I would not be surprised to see this ribbon, it´s awesome work on all the technicals.