Out of Order
by grus

Comment:
this image (IMO) is hurt alot by a bad editing choice...that would be that of desaturating everything but the reds and yellows....other wise i feel it has a verry effective grayscale and fits the challenge well.
thats my 1 gripe.

Untitled
by Tiberius

Comment:
i like this very much..you did a great job of framing it (semitry and that all) and the trash/over grone areas are well captures (tonaly) so everything is visible and nothing gets lost...clearly to me 1 of the better shots in the challenge (espicaly 1 of the better B&Ws), good luck

The "El"
by saiphfire

Comment:
intrusting image, not the biggest fan of the way its framed i know where it is tho :O)

really a nice image over all, the grain fits and isn't over kill

Soft
by PollyBean

Comment:
very nicly done...purfect...good luck

Window to Her Wondrous Soul
by lynnesite

Comment:
beautiful shot, not much grain here, but i like it as aposed to over graining, and if u had taken this shot with film, even if u had pushed the film u prob. wouldn't have gotten more grain out of it......so well done

like the vignette/white/opaque bar at the top, it adds a nice touch creative

When the Day Is Done...
by OdysseyF22

Comment:
this to me is a well done still life with the right level of noise/grain for a photo, u could even go a tad higher, but this is really well done, i can actualy see the subject (which isn't the grain itself) and it has a good staging, and a fair enough framing a little bland and front on, would be my 1 critique- good luck

Howdy!
by parrothead

Comment:
over use, IMO to distracting to help, only hurts at this point, if u backed it off i think u would have the right image for the challenge.
eigther that or B&W might work with the amount of nosie/grain u have in the image now

The Night Tourist
by e301

Comment:
lov it....i wish it was slightly less washy with grain and had alittle, just a smidge, more clarity...still 1 of my top for the challenge

Its Time Has Passed
by SteveJ

Comment:
very nice framing and composition....i just don't understand why there blaks in this image are so washed out...the apear a foggy gray/black color....if only they had a very deep tone to them...a true black...man this image would be in my favs. as it is i think u came really close but need to mess with curves to have the full impact this shot could bring

Twilight Time
by RKT

Comment:
there is a real odd controdiction of smooth and grain here primarly in the tree line...it doesn't apear as even as the eye likes to see it