Walk Him Every Day
by Konador

Comment:
Well Mr Konador, this is one of the better Dog pictures I have ever seen. Seems like you just happened to take this shot, and decided to throw it into the challenge, rather than actually taking the shot specifically for the challenge. To combat that you probably should have shown the dog in such a way as to imply you were doing something with him - i.e walking him. Of course a shot like that would be almost impossible to make as aesthically pleasing as the above shot. Considering, then all this could be said for any number of the images in this challenge, I'm not going to hold that against you. 9.

IMG_3487dpc.jpg
by hsteg

Comment:
Where is this one taken ? It's too early for the Quebec city carnival isn't it ? Quite like the shot - though that wacky blur on the left is a little bizarre.

A Hundred A Day While My Mind Runs Wild
by Coley

Comment:
Does Gary K walk among us mere mortals again ??

I really can't put my finger one what makes this image so effective. There doesn't seem to be anything particularly out of the ordinary about it, yet I feel compelled to give it an 8. That's the power of simplicity I guess. NIce idea, great execution = high score. Simple equation - and one that you have clearly perfected. (apologies if I have the identiy of that shaved head wrong).

broken or bust?
by whiteroom

Comment:
I just came across this. I gave it an 8 during voting but it probably should have been more. It's not all that often that I think an image that scored over 6 was hardly done by. This is one of those times.

He's Soaking in It
by soup

Comment:
INteresting shot - if this was just the hand I wouldnt have been impressed - and would have seen it as merely a lesser version of one of the last waldo challenges ribbon winners. The purple paint is, however, a nice touch, and the little boy figure hidden in the paint seals the deal. 9

My baby's turned into a crunch machine!!
by MrYu

Comment:
Well it works on my (lame uncalibrated) CRT....

Congrats - 2 out of 3.

Yura Machine.

:P

Appreciate The Moment
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Really great silhouette. Nice tones. Overall a joyous image. I think you should have cloned out some of the bushes on the lower right and maybe eliminated the moon, but I like the concept and execution here. 7.

Resist all temptations
by Gauti

Comment:
Really quite clever... Not too fussed about the lighting here - bit dark for my tastes. But I laughed so that's enough to get you a 7.

I will not be afraid to use bigger weights
by nico_blue

Comment:
Good simple shot. Great lighting here. 7.

Multi-A-Day
by smokeditor

Comment:
Interesting idea and execution. The soft focus/ high key effect is terrific here. I'd say the subject matter will likely keep you out of ribbon territory, but your technical skill is tremendous. 8.