Tree Star
by Kanntara

Comment:
Finally a picture that meets the challenge in my opinion with good detail, color, and focus; However the sky is a little burned out and the boarder imo is overpowering, but still a good photo.

The end of the World
by kghoshal

Comment:
I’m sorry but I don’t see anything bizarre about your photo or amazing. Looks like a dirt hill on the backside of a soccer field. However you did a good job of capturing a mars type landscape or as your title say ‘then end of earth’. The goal and out of bound flag [?] to the left is distracting. Lighting is good and photo is smooth

Mouth Wash
by Gobolts

Comment:
Good capture but I think a tighter crop would of made this picture even better. I consider it amazing how a bird can see fish under water and dive to get lunch. IMO you meet the challenge and have a good photo.

Preemptive Defense
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
Very nice micro with great detail, DOF, Focus, and lighting but I see nothing bizarre or anything that makes me wonder in amazement. You have a great picture but imo I does not meet the challenge.

The Sisters
by timmi

Comment:
Great photograph. I wish I had the skills to make a photograph like this. Everything I enter never goes beyond basic editing because of my lack of skill. I would love for you to post in a forum [if possible] after the challenge is over, showing step-by-step how you achieved this. It would help me a lot. Great job!

Autumn Afternoon
by bobdaveant

Comment:
I like the way you took this picture out of the shadows framed by trees. Great color and lighting – good job.

Bizarre Halloween weather.
by cathysapp

Comment:
I'm guessing the weather where you live is not this cold at Halloween, making it bizarre weather. I would of liked to see something showing halloween in the picuture, it almost looks like he is enjoying a christmas gift. I say you meet the challenge and a good photo! Good luck in the challenge.

Photographic Poverty?
by SteveJ

Comment:
did not vote in the ‘poverty’ challenge because I am by all earnings am poverty due to illness that has kept me out of work all year. For that reason I did not think I could vote without being bias, I didn’t want my personal experience effect my scoring, just my decision. It may have been the right judgment or not.
I like your photo it does represent poverty in several ways including the synonyms of poverty.
1. You ‘lacked’ the camera you would like to have: lack is a synonym of poverty.
2. You picture showed ‘poor quality’. Not being rude: Poor Quality is a synonym of poverty.
For those reasons, which make your photo meet the challenge and the humor involved I would of given you a 6. Good photo!

IMG_4071- Blue Sky October.jpg
by thatcloudthere

Comment:
I love the negative space in this shot and the colors are great.

down a dark and stormy road
by mrorange002

Comment:
It conveys an autumn feel with the colors and lighting making it great for October Free Study. I really like the subject and it is placement is perfect in my opinion. I think you did a great job. If your entry is better than this, I can̢۪t wait to see it.