Got Milk ?
by BruB

Comment:
This is a really great photo and advertisement. Cookies are in great focus, but focus seems a little lost on the glass of milk. Also, I'm not sure whether you need the reflections in the bottom of thte picture, but doesn't necessarily take away from the photo. Definitely a 9!

Woodpecker says BUMP....just for fun
by Brooklynsbridge

Comment:
I'm not sure this photo meets the challenge. I think it's really funny, though!

Too Hot to Candle!
by BearSilber

Comment:
I'm not sure I like the soft focus on the candles in this photo. I am not tempted to buy any of these candles. A product generally needs to sell itself or be associated with something great - and unfortunately, neither appears to be happening in this photo.

All Natural
by briphoto

Comment:
Great photo. The fruit in the picture makes me thirsty! Maybe turning the canister a bit so that "Welch's" stands out more... that could help. Overall, this is one of my favorites in this challenge. (9)

Cherry coke surplus
by altoidgreen

Comment:
None of the Coke bottles are in good focus, and the brightness levels seem off. I do like the arrangement of the bottles in the photo, though.

Thirsty???
by Damian

Comment:
This is a good close-up shot of the water bottles. Some reflection in the middle label ("LIFE"). Also there is a yellow light reflecting in the right bottle - possibly a flash from the camera? Take away those reflections, and I think you've got a really great photo here.

Yellow Canoe
by v_prage

Comment:
The title indicates the canoe is what you are advertising, but it is too distant in view. It looks like a dark cloudy day or late evening, which you wouldn't associate with fun times on a canoe.

New Hubba bubba girl
by ConcreteDonkey

Comment:
I agree with the others... this was a top choice for me in this challenge, at least in the top ten. This is a wonderful captured moment. Definitely going on my favorites list!

Rites of Passage
by ldallek

Comment:
I gave you a 7 on this picture and wished it rated higher overall. This is a beautifully captured moment. I hope that your family (and others!) enjoy this photo, because it expresses a lot.

On another note, I have no idea how someone could rate your photo a "1"!

View from River Street
by hallswel

Comment:
I voted a 7 on this picture and was disappointed to see that it wasn't scored overall a bit higher. I really love the colors, and the bridge/crane (?) seems to be pretty much in line with the horizon. My only real complaint is that the bridge/crane seems a touch out of focus, but then again that might be an illusion. Nice work, though!