Rusty...The Dog
by Kneeforu

Comment:
I really like this. It is a very cute image, nice colors, nice composition, ant one of really attractive photos of rust.
A 10 and I hope you do really well with this.

Captivity
by maciupiciu

Comment:
I liked the autumn feel this has especially when it is spring where I live. It also has a late afternoon mood. The bends and twists of the heavy iron bars are also very appealing, well lit, and adequately focused to make the photo interesting and appealing.
I would have liked more focus on the very nearest bar and tighter cropping at the top.
A 6.

Past Their Prime (Unedited)
by trnqlty

Comment:
I like the framing of the opening and the variety and positioning of the rusting wheels. Nice focus and depth of field.

I would have preferred a point of view to the right and above that of the current camera position. There is something in the background here that is distracting. I also would have liked less negative space and tighter cropping almost to the edge of the window.
A 5.

Hangin On!
by jazzmanmgt

Comment:
I like colors and focus and point of view.
I would have preferred less depth of field and a lot more cropping. Even though there is rust on the fence, it detracts from the central point of the picure, as does the opposite shore, other boater, and ramp.
A 3.

~
by nfessel

Comment:
I liked: your title, the composition, the power of the barbed wire junction, your excellent use of aperture and focus, the red rust, the quartz quality of the background.
I would have preferred greater complexity in the subject matter. There is not enough here to hold attention for long.
An 8.

Love Bug
by Donatien

Comment:
Liked: One of the best rusting car photos submitted because of beauty of surroundings. The strength of the colors of the subject stand out well against the background.
Would have preferred to see more of car or all of it.
Overall photographic quality is quite good and artful.
A 7.

dying to rust
by ericsuth

Comment:
Liked: use of aperture, colors, focus on immediate foreground object.
Would have preferred. Change point of view so as not to be looking down on gate or fence.
A 6.

Rusty Railway Bridge
by alanfreed

Comment:
Liked: The subject matter. Great depth of field. You cropped as much of a disinteresting sky as you could. This is a lovely view and nearly an excellent point of view on it. The spring foliage really helps.
Would have preferred: The shot be taken just a little further from the right so as to include all of the last rail.
A 9.

Trepans Bucket
by zmaerd

Comment:
Liked: The subject matter. The colors. Photographic quality and photographer skills apparent.
Would have preferred: to have full pail in picture, even greater DOF.
A 6.

Got macho?
by theodor38

Comment:
Liked: Great model, great pose, Colors (orange and blue really go together well,) and obvious effort of model is captured well.
Would have preferred: I would have liked more lighting to diffuse shadow across chest, a shirt which offered greater contrast to the chain, and perhaps more of the shoulders. Also the white balance appears off on the forearms.
A 7.