Rust and water
by grivera

Comment:
It is unfortunate that the rust does not exend out to where the lovely drop resides. I would like to see more lighting on the subject. The overall appearance is that of looking at something in the dark.

A 5.

R.W.S
by UNCLEBRO

Comment:
Very nice, although I would have liked to see the upper part of building which is in shadow from the roof cropped out.

An 8.

boreal scourge
by camelotnorth

Comment:
This shot just misses the mark for me. I would like the background a little more out of focus, not much, and I would like to see a little more of the top of the tree in the foreground. I would like to see the junction of the two branches at least.

A 6.

Rust and Rustproof
by lear202bt

Comment:
Amazed that lock worked enough to insert bracelet. The background however does not work for me.

A 4.

sniper
by hopper

Comment:
What serendipity! A little glare knocks this down to a 9.

The Byre
by andywightman

Comment:
Very nice. I would like to see a little less to left and right. Cropping just to the left of vertical fence post immediately to left of building and just right of red thing in bottom right corner enhances this picture from my point of view. The colors in the stone are wonderful. Thanks for taking and submitting this shot. I personally enjoyed looking at it greatly.

A 9.

Rusty Hydrant
by chan

Comment:
What colors and lighting. The offset angle and seeing the nut from only one side really help this pictures.

I'll go for a 10 on this one. Good luck.

TRASH DAY
by darceybonds

Comment:
There does not seem to be a lot of reason to present the can in silhouette, nor for the sidewalk, nor for the post.

A 2.

Old Abandoned Tractor
by Sammie

Comment:
Thsi is the best farm equipment photo yet. The big tire shadow detracts some but I like the strong lighting and the gorgeous setting, clouds, mountains, snow, and preplowed field.

A 9 for artistic merit.

Water and Rust
by egillibsen

Comment:
Nearly perfect for me. The heavy shadow at top of right pier is somewhat disconcerting.

9, but wish I could give a 9,5, it is that close.