3 Unfortunate Trees in the Path of a Storm
by postoakinversion

Comment:
Great sky! Possibly best of show. Congratulations! I am curious how much post processing was done. I have seen sky just this way but rarely am successful catching it just this way through the lens. Hope you do a tutoril. I'd like to learn. (9)

Three Men Carved in a Mountain
by candycorn

Comment:
I like the picture. Overall steel grey works well. Contrast and levels are great. Comp is good. I am wondering though if this violates the rules about taking a photo of another work of art. Voted as though it was ok. (7)

My car has 2 light sources !
by menardmam

Comment:
Every car on the planet has two light sources. This would have been better if it had given me a clue about what was unique about your car. Is it the location? Or the dust/fog. Might have been better to take the lights out of the photo and just caught the fog. The multiple light sources would still have been obvious.

Techniquely, everything is a bit out of focus and the lights are blown out. Balance of dark at the top and light at the botttom feels overweighted.

Light and shadow
by ckallies

Comment:
Clearly meets the challenge but I don't find anything interesting going on. The centered door (not really the subject of the photo?) draws attention away form the light and shadow. I suppose I could be interested in what's behind the door, but the photo doesn't really force me to ask the questioon.

Sorry, may just be too esoteric for my taste.

Lights Late Evening
by surajbhar

Comment:
Certainly delivers on the multiple light source the theme. But fails to hold my interest. My eye keeps sliding down and to the left to where the 1 is on the voting scale of 1 to 10.

Lofty foundation in Death
by unknowndeath

Comment:
Multiple light sources aren't obvious. I like the high contrast but the levels at the dark end are too intense. Composition could be better, possibly if it were landscape rather than portrait. This may suffer a bit from a foreground/background balance issue.

See the light
by paynekj

Comment:
Interesting idea. Centered subject hurts the overall effect. If you haven't already, suggest you read the "rule of thirds" material. It will help your composition.

Over and under.
by movieman

Comment:
To be honest I can't figure this out. I think I understand what you're trying to do but the composition hurts the effort. This may be a great idea but just impossibly difficult to capture.

untiteld
by Elad

Comment:
Multiple light sources aren't obvious. Technically the photo is a good workmanlike capture except the focus seems a bit off. The shed or tent in the background detracts somewhat.

Keep at it. You have the technical skill. Just apply it to a better subject.

At the concert
by heida

Comment:
We see quite a few "concert images" here and to be honest, I am generally not a fan of them. Generally find it hard to give them more than a 5.

A concert image is very hard to get right. Lighting is often low (or totally blown out). Usually there's a lot of movement. And to be frank, you often can't control where the photo is taken (unless you have better luck choosing your seats than I do.)

So the thing is ... you have attempted a photo with a very high degree of difficulty ... and pulled it off brilliantly. I like almost everything about it (comp, color, levels, contrast if not so much the subject) and it nicely renders the theme. Congratulations! Hope it does well in the voting. (9)