Stone Gazebo
by mlu

Comment:
Something strange is going on in the background of this image. The top left corner looks like there is a wall behind the gazebo, but when I look through the gazebo I see what I assume is the sky. A pitty, because besides that it is a decent image :)

The Classic Sunset
by HalldorIngi

Comment:
I think the shot is great, but for me something is not quite right in post-processing. I'm a newbie, so I can't really say what it is. Still, I like the angel and DOF is really nice.

Remembering The Bay
by Cuttooth

Comment:
I think this is a good shot, but the vignetting is not doing it for me. It is drawing my attention towards a pint in the image where noting is happening. Also,if it was my image, then I think I would have attempted to lighten up the bedrock in the foreground, so that all of it was in the same nice golden color.

Phaon Crescent
by grahamgator

Comment:
Excellent DOF!

Skull of a Monkfish
by pall

Comment:
Nice capture! If I were to comment on something then it would be that I think I would prefer a little less saturation in the sky

Pure
by Bensted

Comment:
The images lacks a bit of contrast in my eyes

Alternate Reality
by Cory

Comment:
Your processing has transformed this "not so interesting" capture into a quite interesting image :)

The end of an excellent day
by markwiley

Comment:
I really like the colours in this image. Quite often I find that people oversaturate these kind of pictures. Your processing is near perfect in my eyes!

4th New York Independent Battery - Devil's Den - Gettysburg Battlefield
by glad2badad

Comment:
I didn't vote on this challenge, but I agree with the two issues raised by atupdate/Tim. I'll add one more thing. To me the image looks cluttered, in lack of better words. This is because of everything going on in the hillside. All of the rocks, shrubs and different coloured grass is stealing my attention away from the actual monument. Of course this is not something you can do anything about, but perhaps a different angle might have done the monument more justice? I don't know..I'm still learning :)

Update: Oh..someone beat me to it. Note to self, refresh window before leaving a comment an hour before the initial viewing of the image

Message edited by author 2015-05-04 10:10:39.

Thinly Veiled
by FromDaRock

Comment:
I'm not sure about the vignetting. I think it might be too much. But nice composition and gorgeous lady.