Crumbling
by shutterphunk

Comment:
Interesting photo and very well done. altho it lacks clarity it still has a nice appeal to it. Well done and good luck in this challenge.

no-one to bother ya...the owner's dead.
by reification

Comment:
To much grain altho it does have a unique effect. It adds a unique quality to this photo but I'm not sure how much that will hold in this challenge. Good luck with this challenge.

shattered
by messerschmitt

Comment:
I realy like the look of the broken glass and think this will do very well in this challenge. ot many photo's in this challenge I have come across yet that make you actually stare into the photo and really feel it like this one does. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <8>
This is my highest score I have give out yet. Will be back to re-evaluate.

Elect Miz
by charmayne

Comment:
I find this photo to be to dark. Not much you can do tho because if you brighten it then it would have lost even more. good luck in this challenge.

homestead
by ralph

Comment:
This photo does not suggest to me it is abandoned but in ruin. It also looks more like a silhouette then a building. There is also a sun spot on your lense. You can see it on the second stone? from the bottom right and it is very distracting. Excellent colors tho. Good luck in this chalenge.

Abandoned Building
by alonzo76ok

Comment:
To much landscape not enough building. The contrast has made the colors look blown out or washed out and makes the photo overall look bland. Good luck in this challenge.

On The Outside Looking Out
by geofffox

Comment:
Would have made for an excellent photo for the windows challenge but for abandonded building I find it lacks interest/subject. I also find the focus/clarity to be a little OoF as well. A border on this photo could have done well as it would have made the photo stand out more. Good luck in this challenge.

Derelict
by Picture This

Comment:
Nice photo but looks to be way to much USM. Beautiful B&W conversion and I kinda like the photo but it lacks clarity/definition. I find the contrast to be a little to bright as well. Well done and good luck in this challenge.

Left for dead
by rayg544

Comment:
There is a fine line between abandoned buildings and buildings in ruins. This looks to me like it is in ruins. A very interesting composition tho.

Grain Elevator #2 - R.I.P. since 1996
by labuds

Comment:
A beautiful shot but the water makes it look very unreal. It looks like a mirror image with no ripples in the water. Excellent shot with great colors and clarity. Well done and good luck in this challenge.