In the Gym
by karmat

Comment:
Nice shot. I'm actually surprised that this is the only "smelly shoes" entry in the contest. I expected more. I like the b&w. I gave this a 7.

Pipe Smoking
by Yankl

Comment:
This is different from the other shots in this contest. I really like it. Nice background and lighting. I like the way he's holding the pipe and the look on his face. Definitely a plus (for me) that he's looking away from the camera. The semi-side shot is really nice. Good work. I gave this an 8.

Love it or hate it
by jonpink

Comment:
Love it! Love this shot too. :-) Good color, sharpness and layout. Like how you brought a few cloves away. Kind of wish the entire image was in focus. That bottom left corner keeps pulling my eye to it. Nice work. I gave this an 8.

Winter Fresh Peppermint
by pcody

Comment:
Pretty simple idea, but it looks very nice. I like the use of artifial snow. There seems to be a hint of yellow in the white of the candy canes in the top left. See how much whiter the ones in the bottom right are? Must be something with the lighting. I gave this an 8, though.

Pine
by deemer

Comment:
Quite a simple shot, really, but I like it! I like the border too. The colors and sharpness are good. Nice job. I gave this an 8.

Hot Candlewax
by hughletheren

Comment:
Not a terribly bad photo, but it doesn't do much for me. The title doesn't match the image. This looks like a brand new candle that you lit, snapped one quick picture and immediately put out. I don't see any "Hot Candlewax". Barely visible is a slight indentation where a bit of the candle melted. The smoke is okay...but you can see the beginning and end of it and it again proves my theory of "light it, snap it, put it out". The image also seems tilted too much CW. A slight CCW rotation of this image would straighten it up nicely. The black background is solid and nice. Hope this helps.

POOOOOOOT!
by dadas115

Comment:
I'm not sure how this fits the challenge. If you can email me I'll adjust your score accordingly.

Freedom
by PERCOM

Comment:
Great shot, but I'm not sure how this fits the challenge at all. If you can email me I'll adjust your score accordingly.

Sweet duck
by Dejan

Comment:
I'm not sure how this fits the challenge at all. If you can email me I'll adjust your score accordingly. Not a bad shot, btw.

by a creek in the Australian bush
by amwab

Comment:
Very small image and I have no idea what it is. To me it's just a shot of a weed. I would not know by looking at this if it has anything to do with the challenge topic. Please shoot me an email with more information about this and I will adjust your score accordingly.