Transcendental Number
by lisae

Comment:
Thanks for all the comments! I know the photo has its faults, in aligning the numbers, etc. However, the transparency was clipped to some glass, which I stood up in the sand, and then I hollowed out a space for my camera in front of it (put a towel down to keep it safe :)). Because of this, I couldn't see the LCD screen at all, so it took a lot of trial and error just to get it this well aligned!

If I'd had time to reshoot, maybe it would have turned out better.

The Hand of Pi
by magnetic9999

Comment:
This is quite cool. Perhaps there is a bit too much going on in it though. The layered elements dilute one another, so the overall impact isn't strong.

= 4 points
by johnny_justjohnny

Comment:
Nice idea. Is there a coffee stain underneath the letters though? The photo overall has a dirty feeling.

π rSour
by justine

Comment:
The slightly off-centre composition just makes it look as though you wanted to avoid centring the lemon. I prefer composition to have an artistic reason behind it. The colours seem washed out.

Tactile Calculations of Pi
by dsidwell

Comment:
I like the composition of this photo, but it feels a bit too big and square. The tonal depth is a bit lacking too.

Pidial
by helgihelgi

Comment:
I really like this photo. Great DOF, great composition, and really nice, rich colours. The textures are lovely too.

Lemon Meringue Pi
by shareinnc

Comment:
Very washed out. I can hardly see the ruler.

Banana Pi
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Interesting idea, but I'm not sure if all the negative space really works. I think it weakens the impact of the bananas rather than strengthening it. I love the colours in this though, and the lighting is great.

Pi with an E
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
This is one of the less interesting pie shots. It's washed out and grainy, and the pie itself isn't highly visually appealing.

Play doh Pi
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
I like the bright colours and the high contrast in this. It's better than a lot of similar photos in the challenge. The camera angle adds depth, and the white background keeps it clean and simple.

Yet, it isn't a highly artistic image. It still seems more like a photo that was designed to meet the challenge rather than be a work of art.