safety first (barbed-wired fence)
by redpanda

Comment:
That looks like razor wire, not barbed wire. I think that this might have been stronger if photographed nearly parallel to the fence, perhaps looking through the tube formed by the razor wire.

Silhouetted Pine
by channeled

Comment:
This image seems to have an odd color cast to it. Aside from that, I like the image.

Australian Autumn
by stormy

Comment:
I'd like this much better if the person's head didn't merge with the background.

Dusk over the City
by Tallbloke

Comment:
The colors in the water are the most interesting part of the image. The skyline isn't particularly noteworthy, and I'm unable to identify a specific element which you framed as the subject.

Bridled
by Galimages

Comment:
This looks very over-processed.

The Town Steeple
by TommyMoe21

Comment:
Dodging the tip of the steeple was a good idea, but you went so far that the editing is obvious. In my opinion a somewhat more subtle edit would have been much better. Even so, this is one of my top picks so far. I really like the shot's moody feel.

Standing in the past
by kcuman

Comment:
I really like this image, but I can't see how it meets the challenge. The portrait crop mirrors the shape of the frames reflected in the lens, but I think that squaring the image slightly to include a little more breathing room to the left and right of the lens would have improved the image.

One Last Cast
by Gatorguy

Comment:
I like the contrast between the two subjects. However, because this is only a silhouette, the close placement of the two people makes it unclear what their relative position is and they seem to blend together. If possible, I would have had them move farther apart or move the camera to a different angle to increase the separation.

Americas Temples
by chaddybones

Comment:
This might be more meaningful if I could make out what the object(s) silhouetted against the flag are. The restrained saturation works well here.

French Horn
by Pooba

Comment:
I think that this would have been more interesting if it were more abstract or dynamic. As it is it just looks like a bunch of pipes.