Alone
by gys

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Poor little misfit
by jettyimages

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Ready for a caress...
by Rino63

Comment:
At first this reviewer didn't like this image, but after revisiting it three times and finally for a comment, it began to click. A fine effort and a clever way of viewing the subject matter. From a technical standpoint, the top of the image could have been a little more in control, but that's a minor point. Originally rated a six, it has been rerated a eight for being a technical and artistic success and because the reviewer is a complete and total doofus.

Lunar Landing
by aprudhomme

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

What Lies Beneath
by rob_smith

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Heart-A-(t)Tacks
by antje

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting even though the point is being made well. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Where im fromt
by keriboi

Comment:
A very clever concept and an artistic success. Unfortunately, from an technical standpoint, it doesn't quite make the grade. A lot more sharper and crisp image would have helped this a lot. As it stands, it just misses being rated a 8 and possibly a nine. A little more thought while framing and focusing, perhaps even revisiting the image after processing would have been a better choice. A solid entry into the challenge.

Alone In A Crowd
by pamelasue

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Spiny Fruit
by smudgeSMJ

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is on the edge of being good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Sharp as a Tack
by kaiser_chief

Comment:
A technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. The subject is less than interesting and overly relies on the person and not the tack. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.