Old Snuff Mill Bridge, Glasgow, UK...circa 1740.
by GenrOne

Comment:
The bridge does look like an interesting subject, but I don't think this is the best angle to take it from. The trees are just in the way and add nothing to the shot, and you've only managed to capture part of the bridge. I think this would be best taken from down at the water level looking up at the bridge, though I see a metal fence there, so I"m guessing they don't really want you going down there.

A work in progress!
by mileskea

Comment:
Stonehenge is always an interesting subject to photo, but you've done something weird here, possibly over sharpening which has caused a halo around the stones and removed them from the rest of the image. That large white cloud formation also looks a bit odd against an otherwise very overcast sky.

"I heard the mission bell..."
by Photologist

Comment:
This is a great shot all round with some good colours as well. It does have an HDRish feel to it, which usually makes me dislike a photo on first sight, but I think you have handled it well here, apart from the clouds to the top right which I feel are a little overdone and harsh compared to the soft tones of the rest of the image.

I would also like to see a wide angle shot which brings in that wall to the left as well some more, but as it stands I really like this one. 7, and that's only because of the clouds or I would have scored it higher.

Physics lecture #87 - Barlow's Wheel
by vawendy

Comment:
You have managed to avoid what a lot of the other shots in this challenge have suffered from and that is ending up with a photo which simply documents the item. You have a great use of shadow and lighting here, which compliment what is already an interesting (and unusual) object. I don't know what this is, but I can only assume it's part of some light experiment. 8 from me.

Pressing Issues
by CEJ

Comment:
These certainly are old indeed, but it does feel like you have just taken the shot to document them, as though to place in a catalogue to be archived somewhere. Perhaps a much closer shot of just a single one to see some of the detail in the old rusted metal would have been better.

The Old School House
by drake217

Comment:
This is a good shot, one of the better ones I've seen so far. Good use of B&W, though sometimes I think these old buildings can have wonderful colour too. Nice angle as well.

Don't like the sky though, it's ended up looking quite dark and threatening, which is in contrast to the brightly lit building with shadows. I think whatever colour filter you have used has been the cause of that.

1869 Victorian Doll
by elizadeb

Comment:
This like a lot of other shots in this challenge feels very much like it is just documenting the object rather than making a good photo out of it. I think what has caused that here is the background. Also, what I can only assume is a cushion to the left is just in the way.

New York 1902
by The_Dentist

Comment:
I've seen a shot of this building before, though looking down at it rather than up. This is also a nice perspective and I like the fact you can see street detail as well as some motion in the cars. Gives it a real city like feel! 7.

Northfield Lodge- 1842 (Cobblestone)
by smichener

Comment:
Nice shot, though I think it would have been nicer if you had included the whole building. Mind you, I don't know what the rest of the building looks like so I may be wrong, but that's just the impression I get when I look at this.

Heavanly
by phiggins24

Comment:
The building has a nice contrast against the (slightly unusual shade of) blue sky. I do think it would have been nicer if you could have included the whole front of the building though. From this I have no idea just how high you are looking at the building, whether that is the top of a doorway at the bottom of the frame or just an arch in the decoration. Also might have been worthwhile perspective correcting it, even if only a bit.