Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by srafferty:
I don't feel that this has anything to do with the challenge.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by phandes:
nice arrangement of the food mann...I like it~!

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by kawhona:
Its a stretch to make the subject but, a very nice food shot ... good use of background ... couldn't you have chosen some more attractive carbs ?

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by Mambe:
Thanks for the touch of humour !

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
I have attempted to take photos with this basic setup and composition. I know getting the details right is really challenging. Points for degree of difficulty. IMO this would have been better if the subject wasn't so brightly exposed and the background so darkly exposed. There are some blown highlights on the edge of the plate that distract somewhat. I might have chosen a different placemat, or possibly used a wood table. The centered composition is only partially rescued by the single chopstick (?) I don't personally believe the photo meets the challenge but I understand your logic and have ignored the challenge relevance issue. Sorry if this sounds negative, I'm not trying to be hurtful. But maybe it'll help for your next photo.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by bvoi:
Good concept. Too much light on the rim of the plate. White balance is a bit too bright.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by pidge:
I like the idea, but the picture itself is a bit flat. Maybe a bit of an angle or an assymetrical layout on the plate. The dark background is nice because it highlights the lighter coloured food.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by Titia:
I gather you don't follow the diet anymore?....did it help anyway????
I like your humor, I'll rate it a 7.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by CLarson557:
I think this would have looked better at an angle. It is very centered and too much light on the noodles and crackers. Kind of washed them out to make them look rather unappealing.

Thanks to Dr. Atkins
by nbagirl72

Comment by miqqy:
this doesnt seem to have anything to do with the challenge

I apologize for that! I don't think I read the title... carbs obviously!
Sorry again

Message edited by author 2005-07-13 00:16:52.