Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by arnit:
Great shot! Excellent composition. I can't find anything wrong with this picture. It's just perfect. I'm not used to give out 10's. But here ya go: 10!

L'etranger
by greenem2

Comment by psychephylax:
A visit from the Critique Club :)

Wow, I really like the atmosphere of the photo. I think this is an excellent photo. You managed to capture the scene as you say it was in real life. The only minor complaint that I have is that black blob that looks like a garbage container seems to add another "person" into the photo. I love the repeating lights and the lines. The placement of the person is almost perfect too but maybe move him a tiny bit more to the left.

Smile!
by greenem2

Comment by carsten:
A lovely shot. Perfect in black and white. Great composition and the focus is good. The border is good too. One of two favourites this week. Good luck!

Smile!
by greenem2

Comment by arnit:
Great contrast. Good tone. The DOF is excellent. Great job.

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by inspzil:
Too much clouds. Black and white was a good choice for this pic. Nice job - Inspzil

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by agwright:
composition is great .... 10

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by artemis8:
I think this would have been a better photograph in color. The mass of gray cloud in the upper right quarter of the picture is too undifferentiated in tone to make an interesting black and white photo.

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by Konador:
I think the amount of sky you included is great, it sets this photo apart from others in the challenge. Excellent. 10.

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by sylandrix:
Though the sky is dramatic, I do find there is too much of it, and the most interesting parts of the sky are closer to the bottom. Since the most dramatic portions of your image are all in the lower 1/6th of the photo, I think having a panormic crop of just the mountain itself with some sky above it to be a better frame for the photo. Quite a good capture nonetheless!!

Tranquility
by greenem2

Comment by mspearman:
Awesome black and white.