Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by dagaleaa:
Atkins diet here......but, your bread & wine looks good enough to eat & drink! nice photo

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by Mona:
Fantastic.

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by GolferDDS:
Very nicely constructed still life. You have done a very good job with the lighting, backround and placement of the subjects.

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by aussie:
Simply a beautiful photo. I absolutely love the colour co-ordination here and the lighting. The image is not too busy with objects filling the frame. Overall a lovely image that certainly portrays a message. Well done and GL in this weeks challenge.

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by amazoneea:
Wonderful.... so simple,yet so complete... I just love the composition and the theme. Not too sure about the shadows though... Maybe a bit harsh. But I would still give it a 10. I wish it ribbon!

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by justine:
The velvet red drape is awesome here. I think the light could of been dimmed a hair, but this is still very good. Pleasant to look at.

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by Neuferland:
Nice shot. An 8

Bread and Wine
by e301

Comment by smellyfish1002:
Religious connotations, or just happy to have a simple meal??? Either way, this is an excellent still life. Great lighting, composition, and I like what you did with the folds in the background. Good luck in the challenge! JD

In a previous existence
by e301

Comment by e301:

Originally posted by dsidwell: I suppose you mean "in a PREVIOUS existence?" No matter. I love the point of view here,and your lighting could not be better. Super work!

Note for future confused readers of this comment: photo originally titled 'In a pervious existence' - just a typo - but I found a way to correct it :-) after voting.

Weapon of Mass Destruction
by e301

Comment by Neil:
Greetings from the Critique Club:

A well done image, with good tones, contrast and lighting. Composition is also very good.

Perhaps the most critical I can be of this image, is simply that of subject: it doesn't stand on it's own. I understand you took it for the challenge, and that may be enough. Beyond that, I'm not sure where it's going: It's not recognizable by most (actually, at first I thought it was a carburetor!), yet its not really an abstract by most definitions (or at least mine: having stronger form or pattern focus than it is a pictoral representation of the object). And from a pure aesthetics, it's probably not something that I would hang on the wall.

But it's a very good capture for what it is and what you were using it for.