P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by streetpigeon:
The color image has a freshness of a new day feel that is quite appealing, the bright grass and effulgent horizon. The dog is, as some have said, more picked out in this version. However, I like the b & w version just as much, distantly related as it superficially appears. I like that you must look deeper, for that's exactly how to spot animals in the wild. The trees are more prominent and function as witnesses, even distractions. I admire your efforts.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by mariuca:
I like the feel in both pics. The one in color is very touching should you crop and leave the doggie only. I know you try minimal but even in B&W Katee needs the stage without the tv in the background

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by digifotojo:
I agree with the harsh feeling on the b/w image..grass looks almost prickly. The color version adds an overall warmer feeling. It all depends on the kind of impression you're attempting to achieve. The b/w version is definitely more artistic. I think comparing the two tends to alter one's visual experience. The b/w version is a better image overall.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by digifotojo:
The B/W image works better here, not a fan of the OOF look but that's just me.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by insteps:
Agree with jagar again... he seems to know what he's talking about. My only advice would be to use Viveza to bring out some detail in her face.

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by insteps:
ART5 is a little harsh for this subject. Less contrast with more gray tones would work better. I'd probably keep it as color unless b&w was required.

agendas
by roz

Comment by insteps:
Roz, this is terrific! Some anticipation and tension along with beautiful geometry. A lethal combination. I agree with jagar about the border. This image doesn't need faux finishes or gimmicks. KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) works best sometimes.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by MargaretNet:
Not sure about this as everything is blurred so it is difficult to see the subject (?)

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by MargaretNet:
Agree with jagar's comment, the in-camera B&W treatment does not work in this case. I also personally object to calling processing in camera "minimal" ;)

agendas
by roz

Comment by MargaretNet:
Great composition but I am not sure with the old photo PP is the best choice in this case.