shore
by whiterook

Comment by jomari:
I know you are going to be penalized for such a small image, but it is a beautiful little image. I love those golden tones and the uncluttered image.

shore
by whiterook

Comment by ThingFish:
Just a leetle beet too small. You are allowed 800 pixels wide so why not make use of it?

nighttime
by whiterook

Comment by Paul:
I'm going through the entries, stopping at those images I feel have had the benefit of an unconventional eye and dwelling a little longer to try to see and appreciate what you saw. This is one of those images.

Positives: An image at the threshold - I've looked at it on my laptop and I see the moon and a few branches and something occluding the moon on the left. Then I tilt my screen and the whole scene emerges. That is somewhat interesting.

Critical stuff: The above (in my view) is not enough. The overall enjoyability of the image is quite low.

Overall: I can appreciate the minimalistic thing going on here but in the final analysis I'm not really a fan.

nighttime
by whiterook

Comment by Lydia:
People want to see details in the moon if it's the only thing in the shot. (not voting)

nighttime
by whiterook

Comment by Abra:
A very nice and interesting capture of the full moon.

old car
by whiterook

Comment by BrennanOB:
A bit more sharpening in post processing would have gone a long way with this image, we are so used to super sharp car advertising images that the softness here will really hurt your score. Nice light used well to show off the car's shape.

old car
by whiterook

Comment by giantmike:
A good subject for this challenge, but the photo itself doesn't impress me.Too many blown highlighters, no details in the shadows, and distracting background elements.

before Dawn
by whiterook

Comment by oscarthepig:
cutout nailed it. IMO, this is one of your finer, artier offerings. I'm surprised you didn't get a posthumous comment on it. I really hate the aspect ratio, though.

morning clouds
by whiterook

Comment by sacredspirit:
Needs just a little more to make it really stand out, and be interesting.

old car
by whiterook

Comment by dertyklobb:
Come on, this is a photography contest, not a place to show a cool thing you took a picure of.