Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by Bolti:
Hey from the Critique club

Fits The Challenge - Ummm sure, but the motive is not very intresting.

Composition - I would say you need to check out things like rule of thirds and stuff just to get your composition running.

Background - Blue? Not very intresting.

Digital Processing - Is there actually any?

My Opinion - I am not impressed with this image and I will not even take the border into my considiration. People have different views about borders and I think neither for or against them.

Well to the image, The subject is not very intresting, its from a very simple angle and I think that this sure could have been a good photo with some angle work and then some cool B&W conversion or something.

Well I don't know how much more I can say about this.

I hope you don't take this personaly becouse I think people should get harsh critique when they don't do a good enough job.

Regards, Hjalti

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by gg3rd:
The border is too thick. It distracts from your otherwise interesting pic.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by GuGi:
I really like this composition, but not sure if the frame works well (I should refrain from commenting on that :) as I am not good at chosing frames myself) Good shot, I hope it does well.

Doing lines...
by moosemayhem

Comment by ambaker:
Critique Club Review

There are some nice shapes here. The lighting is a bit low, and contrast a little soft.

If this had been taken to extreme contrast where it was almost all white and all black, it would make for increased drama in the piece.

Interesting composition, and focus/depth of field are fine. Just needs more punch.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by glad2badad:
This shouts electricity! Well titled also. The simple blue sky contrasts well with the pole and lines. Good luck in the challenge.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by svstoltz:
This is the best example of ugly overhead wiring so far but it misses the broader issues of social and environmental issues.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by szalona:
good title. unneccessary double border, blakc woudl suffice. cutting off the lamp si a distracting move. i still liek the photo. 8.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by talj:
Great idea, I would have been tempted to crop all of the lamp on the right handside out of the shot as I think its a little distracting. I do like the light on the post against the colour of the sky :o)

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by marycciu:
Nice composition. Attractive image. Frame helps it play out well.

Electric Tree
by moosemayhem

Comment by hotpasta:
I like this, but I think the white line in the frame distracts...