Oldtimer
by
kiwinessComment by FranziskaLang: A Comment From The Critique Club
Hi Gary,
so I finally have time to do a few CC critiques again and I get started off with a winner, what a pleasure :) First impression: I'm stunned. What a wonderful photo full of character and details. I'll have a hard time suggesting anything for improvement ...
COMPOSITION - Very well composed. You filled the frame, got the background blurry but the main subject in perfect focus and still managed to have the guy just a bit off-center to give more room to the direction he is facing. Nicely done. Two tiny little nitpicks on the overall framing are that the collar is cropped off a bit on the left and, since the beard plays such a big role in this photo (at least to me), I'd love to see all of it in the frame, and not the last few straggling bits cropped out. But those are small, the essence of the photo is totally there, the expression on the guy's face, all the details ... great capture at just the right moment.
TECHNICAL - Wonderful. Great focus, and nice blurry background. Good tonal range. Plus, you chose a photo that really lends itself to the Duotone challenge. I bet this photo was good in color, too, but didn't have half as much impact.
POST-PROCESSING - It's well done if you can't see it :) The frame is nice and simple and complements the photo rather than distracting from it.
Overall ... congrats on your new camera and the well-deserved ribbon. I have the sneaky suspicion you'll be getting even more of them soon ... you have a good eye, talent and great equipment :)
Please let me know if you have any questions or comments about this review.
Franziska.