Life of the City
by meyers

Comment by Melethia:
Very nice work and an excellent choice for the challenge. This is one of the shots I thought the desat made sense and was used well. And 97% finish! Congrats!

Message edited by author 2007-05-28 01:51:53.

Life of the City
by meyers

Comment by JuliBoc:
Great shot and wonderful use of selective desat. Congratulations.

Life of the City
by meyers

Comment by g14n:
Wow! Great idea and nice realization. Brilliant!

Two Lives, Overlapping
by meyers

Comment by figaro:
Nice idea and sentiment, but I'd prefer the background to be plainer, it's a bit distracting.

Two Lives, Overlapping
by meyers

Comment by emlbaker:
Looks slightly out of focus to me. Was this done hand held.

Watery Perspectives
by meyers

Comment by jerowe:
Hello from the Critique club, my name is Jon Rowe, and i will be looking at your image this evening :)

Composition/Lighting : composition wise, this seems random but i think it would work if the lighting was quite a bit better, or if a slower shutter speed was used to show flow, then it would be smooth.

Challenge : i really don't see this fitting the challenge, for the main reason of it being incredibly abstract. very nice attempt though. i like the colors, and the natural gradient here.

Conclusion : pretty much got lower score i imagine for the abstract nature of it. the subject itself before shooting i'm sure looked extremely silky and smooth, but the way it was portrayed through your picture in my opinion is somewhat rough and abstract. Keep joining challenges and growing with us all. You're doing well!

Keep on shootin!

Good luck on your future challenges:)
-Jon Rowe

Life of the City
by meyers

Comment by shamer:
Truly great effect!

Life of the City
by meyers

Comment by Beautiful-Joe:
That is wicked awesome, but what is it?

Ahhh! The giant metal jelly beans are overtaking us all!
o.o

Hehe.
Nine.

Two Lives, Overlapping
by meyers

Comment by Dirt_Diver:
Wonderful idea but the image quality here isn't all that great. I would like to see this a bit sharper.

Two Lives, Overlapping
by meyers

Comment by dtremain:
Using thoroughly used rings (not all shiny, new, and smooth) adds a lot to this shot.