Pianista di piano bar
by Rino63

Comment by Retroesque:
Very 'old' feel to this shot - fabulous.

Pianista di piano bar
by Rino63

Comment by violinist123:
Interesting photo. Might have a bit more punch if cropped somewhat tighter to ease up on the darkness at the bottom of the frame.

Walking in Rome
by Rino63

Comment by emayner:
I can see the orange in the photos, but it's competing for attention - it too bright.

Walking in Rome
by Rino63

Comment by cassilda_terry:
wow! i love the picture on the right!

Walking in Rome
by Rino63

Comment by AP:
ah Rome... brings me back a ways... The shots are great, particularly the top left, i just wish you chose a different color for the backdrop...

Brokeh
by Rino63

Comment by sfalice:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Wow, if I had voted on this Challenge, you would have had at least one more high score. So that shows my bias in this critique. I like it; nice work.

However, and with the caveat that I realize you have done a way-down closeup on this, it looks on my monitor as if it was over-sharp. Whether this is the action of your macro set-up or post processing, it could give that impression to an average viewer.

And, yes, it could use just a touch less light on that green leaf. The leaf appears a little 'hot'.

Still, in my book, nice shot.

Walking in Rome
by Rino63

Comment by Jedusi:
Not keen on the orange border - but great shots.

San Pietro
by Rino63

Comment by bdenny:
I'm not a huge grain fan but this seems to work. I like the composition with the woman walking toward you.

San Pietro
by Rino63

Comment by Retroesque:
Grain possibly was a good idea, perhaps too much of it though?

Holy symmetries
by Rino63

Comment by RPvanderHilst:
This one in my opinion has too much snapshot-power :-S -4-