Silverware
by timj351

Comment by arngrimur:
Nice composition and lighting.

Silverware
by timj351

Comment by Konador:
I dont really like the big white area on the spoon, and they look unwashed, which takes away some of the appeal.

Silverware
by timj351

Comment by skylen:
Great, simple composition. I like the colors and smooth textures in this image. However, there seem to be water spots or something on the spoon... perhaps scrubbing it could have cleaned it up a bit. Other than that, a fabulous image.

Hat Trick
by timj351

Comment by Artyste:
Man, I'm kind of glad I didn't see this before doing *MY* shot for Stopped Motion II.. I might have said, "eh, it's been done!" and never gotten my 6.7! :)

ahh.. to have been in challenges 2 years ago :)

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by Imagineer:
Quite simply - I did not question this shot in any way - I just accepted its technical and emotive excellence. What caused this ludicrous rating? Noise? It's grain. Unclarity? Mood. Title? He's a guitarist - just a bass guitar, that's all.

You have, sir, been mightily robbed!! :)

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by Nazgul:
Sorry I intended to quote theSaj "SILLY PEOPLE

A bass is a BASS GUITAR...no different than an ALTO SAXOPHONE... " not timj351

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by GeneralE:

Originally posted by Nazgul: Originally posted by timj351: I screwed up on the title and I know it is a bass. Thanks for all of the feedback, it is greatly appreciated. T That maybe true but I think its fair to say that its not pretty common to call someone that plays BASS GUITAR a Guitarist? what do I know...

No, they're usually called bassist or "the bass player." But this was one of my favorites -- I wasn't marking it down for the title or anything.

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by alanfreed:
Hey, there's no shame in being at the bottom of this pack... I know -- I'm right there with ya! :) I really enjoy your work -- this is still quite a cool shot.

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by Nazgul:

Originally posted by timj351: I screwed up on the title and I know it is a bass. Thanks for all of the feedback, it is greatly appreciated. T

That maybe true but I think its fair to say that its not pretty common to call someone that plays BASS GUITAR a Guitarist?

what do I know...

The Guitarist
by timj351

Comment by floyd:
OMG - how can THIS come last? This was one of my favourites and I gave it a 9. For me this image captured something about what it's like to be at a concert. The grain gives the feel of a smoky atmosphere and the strong light and contrast really evokes the concert mood. Well done on a fantastic shot and shame on the voters for not appreciating it.