The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by wewillexplore:
This shot is amazing. I don't like the fallen DoF on the bottom of the vase, nor the spots of white in the glass - blemishes I guess. I hope you picked the best 'side' to shoot. Otherwise amazing - 10.

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by dsidwell:
Endlessly fascinating abstract in blue and orange! Wonderful composition. and impeccable lighting make this photo really work.

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by labrynthe:
a very nice way to show contrasting colors..... the subject and the background are harmonious thus creating a balanced composition

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by TerryGee:
Absolutely beautiful, strong colors here. I like the abstract quality and composition.

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by marco:
Beautiful abstract shot! The colours came out very well. Sorry, I can only say nice things about this one ;o)

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by qachyk:
Okay, you hit the topical requirement, but I'm afraid the actual composition hurts my eyes.

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by BJ:
What a great photo - love the colors and the composition. Very interesting to look at and I like the white border as well. Good luck in the challenge.:)

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by timj351:
I like this quite a bit but I am wondering if adding some additional glass element would help as a reference for scale or added interest. I'm not sure though. I just feel that it needs something else compositionally. It still looks really cool with great colors.

Love Story
by ursula

Comment by karmat:
CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat

Very nice composition. You have done an excellent job of "filling" the frame without making it look like part of it was cut out accidentally. I like the "curves" between the two, and how they are "nestled" together. The depth of field is awesome in that the details are visible and clear, and the eye focuses on the "stem" of the onion.

My first impression was that perhaps you needed a more obvious secondary color, though you do indeed meet the challenge. To the casual observer/voter, it may appear yellowish instead of orange which is what I think you were going for. Technically and compositionally, this is an awesome shot, and would look wonderful on the wall of a kitchen or restaurant -- maybe a whole garlic/onion series, even.

Good work and best to you in future challenges.
karmat

The Cosmic Vase at Sunrise :)
by ursula

Comment by pitsaman:
Very nice,9!