falling hard
by posthumous

Comment by Mike:
critique club... the tones are nice and its a bit over sharpened for my tastes.

ultimately i feel the image suffers from a lack of a distinct focal point or subject, its equal parts sky and waterfall and i think it need to favor one.

You don't bring me flowers
by posthumous

Comment by levyj413:
Interesting, artsy image, and it connects well with the title. It's just not grabbing my attention. Still, I'm giving it a 6 for visual interest a clear artistic vision.

into darkness
by posthumous

Comment by ambaker:
Critique Club Review:

Color Saturation and Hue - Not applicable.

Brightness and contrast - I'm a pushover for inky velvet blacks... Sold!

Focus and depth of field - Tack sharp, and great depth of field.

Subjective - The bright specks above and beyond the waterfall distract my eye a bit.i really like the angle of the lighting. The flow of the water leads the eye out of the image, which could be a metaphorical vanishing. However the title makes me wonder why the flow of the image does not take me into the darkness.

Overall - another opportunity to seem clueless in front of a master. I'm in love with the backs and the contrasting water.

webwood
by posthumous

Comment by ambaker:
Critique Club Review:

Color Saturation & Hue - Not Applicable.

Brightness and contrast - the lighting seems a bit off to me. I'm a big fan of inky velvet black, but their power doesn't quite gather here. Perhaps more than one light might have helped. As is there are bright spots that fight with the piral for the eye's attention. I'm left wondering if the light following the spiral might have worked.

Focus and depth of field - excellent. The image is tack sharp.

Subjective - I like the image, but find the lighting vs the shape a bit jarring. A bit different lighting could have made this ominous, or another angle might have made it mysterious.

Overall, very daunting to try to critique an acknowledged master...

You don't bring me flowers
by posthumous

Comment by jgirl57:
colors and lighting is very nice..

You don't bring me flowers
by posthumous

Comment by mitalapo:
well shaken

You don't bring me flowers
by posthumous

Comment by tvsometime:
Awww. Very evocative and ultimately sad. A natural triptych.

falling hard
by posthumous

Comment by NiallOTuama:
No HDR!? I'm gonna lobby for this to be disqualified. Shameful behaviour.

Also, it reminds me of some parts of Iguazu Falls.

falling hard
by posthumous

Comment by herfotoman:
Made it surreal. From soft fluffy to hard rock, and the growthpoint inbetween. What's not to like?

falling hard
by posthumous

Comment by mariuca:
Beautiful and stony water. Looks like Don's waterloo cascade! If this is so, I prefer it without the verdure
bump