You Sank My.............
by Phocal

Comment by Melethia:
Fisheyes are an aberration all unto themselves. Interesting shot!

Early Flight
by Phocal

Comment by sidpixel:
Hello from the Critique club

An interesting image that contributes well to the free challenge

A great silhouette. The bird in flight is very intriguing in that it could be flying towards or away from the scene so thanks for your comments which clarify that it is coming towards us, but somehow it feels more complete to imagine it flying away with the two birds passively watching its departure. This interpretation makes the two birds even more appealing their profiles and sharpness being a contrast to the softness of the flying birds wings. I think I would be tempted to remove the large twig and loose feathers of the flying bird to improve the overall impact.

A great score and placing, well done Ronnie

Italian Racer
by Phocal

Comment by sidpixel:
Hello from the Critique club

An interesting image that partially meets the challenge

Creative use of this fish-eye lens has enabled you to present an interesting image of an everyday subject. It has distorted the bike in an appealing way that emphasises the chainwheel and wheels to suggest the potential power that is latently waiting to be let loose. However, the lack of a saddle seriously impedes the end result. As for the challenge brief of image grain although there feels a suggestion of grain it is not very pronounced, given this sort of challenge it needs to be a lot more evident than it is.

Sorry you didn't get any comments during the challenge, I hope this helps. Thanks for your entry Ronnie

Early Flight
by Phocal

Comment by MeMex2:
fabulous capture and beautifully processed!

You Sank My.............
by Phocal

Comment by WonderDude:
What a lens!

Early Flight
by Phocal

Comment by WonderDude:
Excellent silhouette.

Early Flight
by Phocal

Comment by jim29028:
Nice silhouettes, this is a calming image for me, the two birds to the right looking expectant at the return. Looking at this more not sure if the flying bird is coming or going, I'm assuming going away. Nice image.

Fiery Heron
by Phocal

Comment by RamblinR:
Lovely image

Cylon Raider
by Phocal

Comment by snaffles:
Greetings from the Critique Club!

Congrats on the top ten finish, for one! At first I was a little dubious about this pic with the vast amount of oof stuff in the foreground, but it does help to sell the nicely tack-sharp focus on the Raider. Good detail and going from the comments more than a few other people appreciated the sci-fi element you saw and ran with here. Good work, keep it up!

Hope this helps

Susan

Cylon Raider
by Phocal

Comment by jomari:
Simple, elegant, with a strange hint of Darth Vaderish malevolence. Top 3.