In all simplicity.
by DrJOnes

Comment by diegohs:
je.je.je.ej strange photo.. nice.. but strange.ej e.j e

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by basia03:
i skipped voting on this picture as well, because i didn't think i could be fair... too much skin for my taste, but technically very well done and appropriate for this particular magazine... so, i couldn't give it a ten it deserved because i didn't like it, and didn't want to score it lower because it was really good...

that said i find the references to the "laughing horse" inappropriate... you don't have to make disparaging remarks about somebody else's work to discuss the merits of your own.

In all simplicity.
by DrJOnes

Comment by kiwiness:
Very original and very well done. I bet you'll get a lot of exciting comments from the female contingent of DPC :-) Top pic - 9.

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by BigSmiles:
I did not vote on this image because I felt I could not step back far enough to give it a score it would have deserved. She is a very pretty model, she has a nice complexion and great hair however I felt you were pushing it just a bit too much with the revealing bikini (which is tied too tight on the hips btw) So I didn't vote on it cuz I would have likely added another 1 to that list. However, when I look at it again it doesn't deserve a 1, but it does not deserve a 10 either. I would have likely given this a 6 due to small imperfections in the shot itself and also due to what I felt was a bit of tastelessness (her nipples should be covered up completely if it's to be a cover shot..)

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by kosmikkreeper:
Man oh man do I feel your pain... laughing horse indeed!!

In all simplicity.
by DrJOnes

Comment by kosmikkreeper:
Woohooo!! You gotta love the wide angle!!! ;-) 10!!!

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by Kavey:
Your 25 1s will be from the people who found the partial nudity offensive. Not a shock really. Sad but surely somewhat predictable.

For what it's worth I think it's unfair to hit out at the laughing horse shot - like it or not I think it's a superb shot and also one that would be likely to make it onto a cover of magazines on that subject.


----------------------------------
Edit to correct typo. Sheesh! :o)

Message edited by author 2003-06-18 08:02:11.

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by Luckydog:
I feel your pain in seeing some of the voting scores! The picture is not offensive, is very well composed and executed. I say you got everything right. Don't tell the model her "Boobsies" :) were probably too big as she must have spent a fortune getting them! If you need someone to be there when you tell her a laughing horse beat her in the challenge ....Give me a ring!!!!!!

Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment by JPR:
wierd, i didn't even see this shot when i was voting. i could have sworn i voted on all the pictures. anyway, this is excellent and I would have given it a 10 for sure. A 1 is insane.

In all simplicity.
by DrJOnes

Comment by tzsolt:
As a photo is good but it is not a portrait IMHO