All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by mystical_princess:
HI from The Critique Club!
First Let me say I love the title of your image. All in all I think the image is pretty good! A few small things I think you might want to play with on this one. First I think the lamp post and red flower are a tad distracting. I also think this image would be great with a tighter crop, maybe taking out the tree it\'s self entirly, along with the lamp. Since the shadow is the main focus here. The natural lighting and the way you caught the shadow on the wall is great! Excellant focus, nice and crisp shot. The angle is very good, which keeps it from being boring in this situation. I also like that this is a creative take on the Branch challenge. 147 out of 426 isn\'t all that bad. Overall I think it is a good shot. Very good for your 3rd challenge. I hope this critique has helped you a small bit. Good Luck with future images!!
Angie

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by donniev:
geez you must be as old as I am. Nice concept.

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by kena:
Interesting idea, I like it and the composition is good.

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by kylh:
hahah like a kick off from pink flyod
props man awsome shadow

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by KiwiShotz:
Wow, the combination of a stunning architectural shot on its own, plus the tree and its shadow combine to make this a top effort in this challenge. The offline verticals niggle a bit. Not obvious enough to look deliberate/art so maybe just not attended to. Costs it a 10, scores 9

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by Caine:
The wall seems too busy and takes away from the striking shadow cast in the strong sunlight.

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by bowronfam3:
Different....very nice.

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by Bebe:
You made me laugh! Bump one point for amusement.

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by ttreit:
It took me a second but I was pleasantly surprised when I "got it" well done!

All in all... Another branch on the wall
by sbgreen

Comment by cornettcag:
Unique take and pleasant lighting.