WaterFence
by undieyatch

Comment by justine:
Nice reflection. Score 6 Justine

WaterFence
by undieyatch

Comment by sulamk:
Technically correct , exposure, focus, saturation , contrast 7
Good composition 7
Tells a story or creates a mood 7
Impact to the viewer 7
Relevance to the Challenge 8
Overall 7
Sulamk

WaterFence
by undieyatch

Comment by Gracechild7:
If this was sharper it would be a whole lot cooler. Awesome angle.

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by KarenB:
Initial=interesting geometrics
Composition=like how the red triangle points up to the shelves above, which are also in a triangular position
Clarity (focus, details)=Starts out well from the bottom, but due to the darkness at the top, the image becomes dithered. Perhaps some lighting at the top of the shelf would eleviate this.
Exposure=fair
Interesting or Emotive=the geometrics are interesting, but the plastic bag stops my eye from continuing to the top. The other items on the shelf are fine.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by janfries:
I think I see where you were going here, but the clutter on the shelves distracts from the patterning.

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by Antithesis:
I feel like I'm looking at two different photos here. The severe contrast between the top and bottom just confuses me. My eyes keep darting from one to the other.

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background5,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing6,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 6,
Total Averaged Rating6. Autool

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by queen 91:
like the angle.

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by Bea Gagliano:
Cetainly a unique angle but seems a little dark and the plastic bag takes away from that interesting angle.

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment by billyp:
I am rating this shot lower becuase this scene is not specific to your corner of the world. I can see the same setting here is CA. More planning and better positioning/lighting could have made this a better shot. 6