Billboard
by bucket

Comment by blad:
No! Its a giant ! Wonderful view! The BW works very well. Good luck!

Billboard
by bucket

Comment by Catherine_B:
Nice capture but I have a hard time calling a billboard "beautiful" 5 for an interresting image.

decision
by bucket

Comment by arngrimur:
Very good. The expression on her face tells she is making a choise.

Billboard
by bucket

Comment by AlexMonty:
I really like this. Good application of selective desaturation, it works especially well in this shot. You've combined a lot of elements here and I think it's paid off - a 9 from me and best of luck with this challenge!

Alex

Billboard
by bucket

Comment by Shannon:
I really like the use of selective desaturation in this image, very effective, nicely done!

Billboard
by bucket

Comment by caba:
classic work, well done, bumping up

Ground Zero-South End (Project Rebirth Delayed)
by bucket

Comment by Arcanist:
A building covered with plastic. A light pole hovers below it. Without the title, the image would not conjure the word decision for me, however I am certain that journalistically, the image could be used to better tell the story of a council decision. In this case, I cannot simply dismiss the title, but alone it cannot stand up to those images that visualized the decision instead of verbalized the rationale.

There is a journalistically valid reason for the two to link up and be as one. There is a journalistically solid link to the challenge, but I cannot award the caption, the image does not tell me the story of the decision, it shows me the object related to the decision that was made.

The image suffers from darkness followed by a random object of brightness that is slightly distracting. I cannot say that the image alone invokes a sense of decision, but cannot dismiss it in the context presented. I offer a 4 in comparison with other images and the stregnth of the presentation that will not let me completely dismiss this title as something I would read and see in a newspaper. Congratulations on being one of the few to force me into having to give points for a title.

Ground Zero-South End (Project Rebirth Delayed)
by bucket

Comment by JunieMoon:
The light in the lower right seems to distract from the picture. The building is very nice, and the red against the black background gives it power. As a photo it is well composed, but if not for the title, I would not have known what the decision was.

Ground Zero-South End (Project Rebirth Delayed)
by bucket

Comment by dockode:
I don't feel that the image conveys instantly recognizable decision. Interesting pic though.

Ground Zero-South End (Project Rebirth Delayed)
by bucket

Comment by p2jvr:
maybe makes sense for a US citizen. Sorry I do not understand the decision. However, I find the shot too dark so only a middling score.