A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by codauber:
In looking at my disappointing scores for the recent challenge (Reflection Without Mirrors), it makes me wonder if people really looked at my photograph at all. Clearly I could not have used a mirror in my photograph. One apple has a huge bite out of it while the other one does not. I received many DNMC's. This experience has had the positive effect of motiviating me to be a better reviewer- taking time to actually study a picture before I assign a score. But I wonder if other members have had the same frustrating experience.

[user]//www.dpchallenge.com/image.php?IMAGE_ID=423025[/user]

Message edited by author 2006-11-15 12:17:02.

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Virginia Leone:
"Without" mirrors....

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Army of nOne:
Uh, isn't that a mirror?

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by posthumous:
let's see, you put a mirror in the shot and your non-mirror reflections are tiny and subtle. You get my "non-DPC 7".

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by dreamy:
MNMC

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Younger:
Hmmm, I guess you already know that this lookslike a mirror. DNMC IMO.
Nice idea, tho and a good photo.

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Bugzeye:
Clever idea and nice job making the frame look like a mirror. Has anyone given you a DNMC yet? I am sure a few will say, No Mirrors etc.. Hopefully the majority will see it correctly. Good Luck with this.

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Zapatka:
after learning what this really is, my vote quickly changed :)

good job.. you convinced me that it was a mirror..

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by JuliBoc:
DNMC. Certainly looks like a mirror is used in this shot. Nice image though.

A Study on the Reflective Surfaces of Red Delicious Apples
by codauber

Comment by Citadel:
From the challenge description: Creatively photograph a reflecting surface that is not a mirror while keeping your camera out of the shot

Sorry. DNMC