The Red Coats
by edc1

Comment by e301:
Good detail, good strong colours, exposure is fine. I'd perhaps hope for a touch more spark compositionally - this seems just a touch straightforward, which makes it a not-quite image for me: there's a sense of not really knowing what your real point of concentration is here - the coats, the smoke, he decoration, the flasks and bags? Too many elements competing for attention perhaps.

The Red Coats
by edc1

Comment by Antsy:
I love that fire you captured coming out of that barrel. Sweet shot!

The Red Coats
by edc1

Comment by Habatchi:
Excellent photo. Everything is there..Color, detail, lighting..all that is missing is the sound of the muskets

The Red Coats
by edc1

Comment by Falc:
I really love historical re-enactments. I feel the crop would have been better slightly higher, more heads less trousers, but good work all the same.

The Red Coats
by edc1

Comment by madcrabber:
awesome image. way to shoot the redcoats. 9

Last Words
by edc1

Comment by Rino63:
good the black and white and good the details on the hands. I like the black and white and I think that is a good choice here. I found two problems in this image. booth with the space. the first is the too big rope, it hide all the am. the second is that there isn't a good space near the scene. i prefer a minor close-up effect on the hand. 7
best regards

Last Words
by edc1

Comment by vasilyi:
great lighting

Last Words
by edc1

Comment by fireserpent:
The bound hands theme is a little overdone in this Challenge. But, you've done a great job of delivering more strength to the image as others I've seen along the same lines. This would be one I'd print and hang on my wall.

Last Words
by edc1

Comment by Alain:
Powerfull. Great picture.

Last Words
by edc1

Comment by Bolti:
Very nice feel and B&W effect