Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by HBunch:
*Critique Club*

I can honestly say that while this is definately different...it doesn't do much for me.
The only real area of interest is the rock in the bottom right and it's really not clear enough to focus on. The reflection of the rock is distorted and blurred as well, and that's really where I look first before looking in the bottom right.
The large black blob in the center does not add to the photo in my opinion at all either. It seems to have a pixeled area in the center of it and lacks any real purpose except to seperate the photo in 1/2.
Speaking of seperating the photo in 1/2, I think that it's seperated in a bad place. Dead center is a bad 'horizon' spot, and this is no exception despite not being a real horizon at all.
You've heard it before, the border is aweful. Why did you chose grey? And why so huge? I think a simple thin border would have worked much more effectively on this.
I think it may make an interesting abstract, but it's not really my kind of thing. Please take this as only one opinion, as I'm sure you and many others are more into abstract feeling photos.
~Heather~

in the mood for a spring breakfast
by redpanda

Comment by ericsuth:
ok...so where's the breakfast...now I'm hungry :)

in the mood for a spring breakfast
by redpanda

Comment by Philos:
Although I don̢۪t say this is a bad picture I have scored this low.
Low in my book is not extremely low, but I guess there will be other people thinking the same way I do who don̢۪t leave a comment.
Don̢۪t take this the wrong way, this is my own opinion, and I am trying to let you understand what some voters may think.

In my opinion this does not meet the challenge, the description of the challenge: Take a picture that captures an emotion.
I looked hard, but I don̢۪t see an emotion. This could be my fault, but that̢۪s the reason why I voted lower as I would normaly do.

in the mood for a spring breakfast
by redpanda

Comment by Blim:
Nice capture! I'd wish to be there! What a pitty the photo is a little bit too small.

in the mood for a spring breakfast
by redpanda

Comment by justine:
Cute idea but I think we're seeing too much of this. Busy. A tighter crop would of served this better. Great idea and creative.

Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by pawdrix:
This is a nice image but the border in my opinion doesn't really work.

Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by emorgan49:
uh oh - the "border patrol" is going to hate this border. It seems to wide and too grey to me. Also the border color is a warm grey and the water colors arre all cool.

Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by Catherine_B:
unusual and technically ok - just not a very compelling image 5

Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by Shannon:
Don't care for this border at all.

Fish' horizon: my sky is my (reflected) ground.
by redpanda

Comment by BobsterLobster:
Interesting shot, but your border seems to have gone a bit mad.