Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by lionelm:
I like the shot, the colors, its 'documentary' aspect but does not meet the spirit of a 'candid moment' to me, what is happening that makes it candid ?. Another Week 6 or 7. This week 4

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by nborton:
wow, so candid. not really

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by Swashbuckler:
Other than the clutter and the partial people in the background, this is a wonderful photo. I'm at a bit of a loss on the challenge, but that's normal. I guess you could say that all shots of inanimate objects are candid......10 Swash

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background5,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing5,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 6,
Total Averaged Rating5. Autool

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by owennnn:
mood captured - remembrance
sincerity of expressions - average

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by alanfreed:
It's an interesting image to be sure, but I don't see how it in any way lives up to the "candid" requirement.

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by johnmk:
The problem with this picture is the load of details. In the original picture that may have been a good point, but down at 640x480 it is getting blurred. In short the picture is lacking focus on a particular point; the person that has been photographed candidly does not evoke an emotion, since we cannot see what she is relating to in particular. Technically the picture is OK, lighting, focus, but that is not what makes a good picture, it is only a starting point.

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by smshats:
Not a bad shot, just to busy.

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment by justine:
Good impact, emotional. Would like to have seen better light here, lots of detail is lost. Score 6 Justine

Childhood
by mscott821

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background6,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing6,
Challenge: Does your entry meet it?7,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 4,
Total Averaged Rating6. Autool