Late Afternoon Birdie
by spiderman

Comment by Paulk:
Shadow in the foregound seems out of place

Manhattan Beach January
by spiderman

Comment by CreativeFlyPhoto:
with the placement of the sun it looks as if the tree is glowing! great shot

Custom Tint
by spiderman

Comment by Annida:
Hello from the Critique Club!

Composition:
I like your composition. It's very strong and definite. You definitely KNOW what you're looking at. I like the fact that you can't see the rest of the car, it makes it a bit of an abstract.

Background:
Black, nice and simple.

Camera work:
The image is a bit over exposed on the right just above the mirror. Other than that, it looks ok.

Digital Processing:
Hmm... There's some really strange artifacting from your processing, and I don't think it adds to the image at all. I think a nice matte finish would have looked a lot better (in my opinion). Other than the artifacting, I can't suggest much else.

My opinion:
I like this photo, and I like the unique tinting on your window. I like the fact that it fits the challenge very snuggly, and I think there's a lot of potential! Great work, I always enjoy your pictures :)

Manhattan Beach January
by spiderman

Comment by jerrft:
poor re-coloring. is water supposed to be red?

Delicate Extraction
by spiderman

Comment by lisae:
Interesting idea, but I don't think it makes a nice photo. The composition just doesn't work for me. The hammers lead my eyes out to the sides of the photo. I think a bit more asymmetry would have helped.

Manhattan Beach January
by spiderman

Comment by DJLuba:
Amen to Manhattan Beach! Consider yourself lucky. Great capture.....this is the perfect clique

Delicate Extraction
by spiderman

Comment by sanandan:
ice thought!! I feel the shape of the yellow is truely depicting the delicate extraction, and is in contrast with the hammer action. Was the title an after thought or it was planned like that right from the beginning??

Manhattan Beach January
by spiderman

Comment by Anachronite:
fabulouso... meets the challenge with sheer perfection... plus it\'s very technically sound... only shots with more wow factor will score higher

Delicate Extraction
by spiderman

Comment by Sonifo:
Very creative. I even like the paper. It would have looked good with the eggs in a pan and a black background. Anyhow. Good job.

Manhattan Beach January
by spiderman

Comment by basia03:
striking!