Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by Lydia:
4.5236 (I gave it a five) Just not interesting enough to make it in this "free study" challenge, in my opinion. Perhaps in the current "numbers" challenge it would score more highly.

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by Jules1x:
The image just didn't interest me terribly, I was not able to make a connection with the reason this shot might have been taken and the image seemed kind of flat - I might have enjoyed the image more had I been able to see more depth to the rocks. 5 from me.

Push and Pull
by mlhannah

Comment by RianBotes:
Greetings from the Critique club

Ok... classic case of missed opportunity. This has so much potential in it and this rock has allot going for it. Dark mood and as the main theme in this image I would have composed - or cropped this slightly different. Not sure that the horizon in the middle helps this. Yes it was a dark and gloomy day but the processing lets it down a bit and I would have used a bit more contrast. I almost want to play with this image myself but this is your interpretation and the way you intended for viewers to judge it, yet it wont draw attention or interest as it stand here and you also are not putting enough emphasis on your main subject when you dont use all possible tools you have. A square crop is perfect for this but with horizon and other elements placed wrong you loose the plot.
On the scene when taking this I would have also dropped the ISO and upped the F stop for a longer exposure.. at least as long as you can get and judging from your notes you could maybe have gotten to almost a second. Trying to smooth out the water creating further contrast with this solid rock and smooth surface.

Enjoy experimenting and hope the notes help in future challenges.

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by ray_mefarso:
high five for you and your imagination! (also a metal band that I would rate at about five fifteen) predicted score: 5.89

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by Catherine_B:
LOL - the subject and your score are alike? Nice exposure and texture in this image - 5.7

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by illini75:
Should have used this for the numbers challenge. A 4

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by pamb:
I like the play of light and shadow across your image. 5.68

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by giantmike:
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.

Different thought on the challenge, and I think you may be very close. I gave you a 6.

My guess: 5.23

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by jgirl57:
LOL This is really comical I laughed at this LOL

a 5 it is and i bet your avg will be around that as well, I will laugh if that is what you got

Low Fives
by mlhannah

Comment by mariuca:
Let's call it 5.2