The Pond
by Kathyc

Comment by mycelium:
Nice tonal range, especially in the middle greys. Might be interesting to see a cropping of this with the horizon a bit higher.

The Pond
by Kathyc

Comment by MWitt:
Excellent exposure with good tonal range. Good use of the reflections, I like it.

The Pond
by Kathyc

Comment by jpochard:
I really like the tones in this shot, and the reflection is great. It's a good, clear shot, but something about the composition and subject is lacking for me. I'm not sure what it is. There's a lot going on in the photo, and the b/w probably makes it appear busier than it really is because of the similar tones throughout. In color, my eye would have some natural "sections" of the photo on which to focus. It looks like a pretty spot, but I'm not sure if I think it's the best location for b/w. I still scored this pretty high because I thought you did do a good job with the b/w tones, and for the clarity of the shot. Hope this is helpful.

The Pond
by Kathyc

Comment by ClickNSee:
Beautiful capture. This should be on the December page of the Calendar <8>

November
by Kathyc

Comment by StormyWeathers:
It's got almost a vintage look to it. What after shot adjustments did you do?

Crocheted Edges 1
by Kathyc

Comment by stephpax:
Seems a bit too bright to me, and maybe a little soft on the focus 5

November
by Kathyc

Comment by Intelli:
You've been spotted!! Cool shot. Seems to be some noise, but it still looks good.

November
by Kathyc

Comment by Kylie:
Excellent wildlife photo! For a literal calendar shot, not sure that this is what I would want for a month due to the overall gray tones, but that is just a personal taste and not part of my scoring on this.

Crocheted Edges 1
by Kathyc

Comment by Konador:
Try applying USM to this after resizing to sharpen it and bring out the details better. Its too blurry at the moment.

November
by Kathyc

Comment by Gatorguy:
Nice work. It looks cold in November where you are.