Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by dockode:
I didn't feel that the image conveys instantly recognizable decision. But upon meditating about the subject, this is the universally ("THE USA") accepted method for proposing. Thus you have given the viewer the option of accepting. Seeing as how I'm a guy... this photo might have worked out better if there was another subject in the photo to accept. The other subject would not have been enough in that case though, they would have to be showing joy ("accepting") or pushing the ring away ("declining") to show that a decision by one party had been made. But since this photo would work for the other gender, I am giving it a 5.

After the Rain
by DefyTime

Comment by bucket:
Effective tones..composition works, the black background a strong choice-it compliments the desaturated look.

Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by edwalk74:
Nice Idea. Great lighting and composition. I hope you do well - 10

Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by RobotBanjo:
My favorite wedding one! Great job.

Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by nikuser:
Black and white really adds to the atmosphere

Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by hvellur:
humm.... nice picture and a very nice idea

Will you...
by DefyTime

Comment by Barry:
For this challenge I have ignored all titles attached to the images and looked for images that would stand on their own to meet the challenge descrption.....

Meets challenge description......3
Artistic.........4
Technical.........4 image is not sharp

Average.........3

Got Hot Milk?
by DefyTime

Comment by aimee_skittles:
mmm.... looks soo yummy. I have some milk in my fridge that I can heat up if you'll let me borrow the chocolate. ;)
Excelllent pic, I like the cropping.

After the Rain
by DefyTime

Comment by strangeghost:
Very nicely done and love the crop. I'd love to see this in vibrant, highly saturated color though. This shot seems to cry out for vivid greens against a softly blurred background. Having chosen the BW though, you've achieved a beautiful tonal range and very pleasing depth. Nice job!

After the Rain
by DefyTime

Comment by lastef:
Great contrast, great lightning, good idea but there lack the flower to catch my eye, I think that using the rule of third to place some of the stronger flowers there might make it stronger. But it is just my humble opinion and I am not very good at this.