Stranded
by phoozt

Comment by Nuzzer:
Hi from the Critique Club

First impressions are that the processing is over the top. That may sound strange given DPC often likes that but in this instance it feels wrong. Perhaps because the image is so narrow. Why is that?

The subject feels crammed into the frame, although general composition is good.

Once I look at the shot for a while (something many voters may not do) I see that the tones are good. It's really just the reds in the shipwreck that seem too much. I know it's a shipwreck because you said it was - otherwise I'm not sure it's that obvious. That would have hurt the score a bit.

I feel that if the shot was another inch or so higher then you'd have got a much better score.

stormy weather coming up
by phoozt

Comment by stevieian:
I like the coloring and upward POV. A bit more light on the face perhaps.

Stranded
by phoozt

Comment by phoozt:
it's shipwreck..

stormy weather coming up
by phoozt

Comment by BJokerud:
A beautifull photo, but I would like to see some form of fill light lighting her face abit. Lovely little girl =)

Stranded
by phoozt

Comment by treimee:
Like the colors. The size seems awkward to me.

stormy weather coming up
by phoozt

Comment by hotpasta:
great perspective...the highlights are quite blown out though 6

Stranded
by phoozt

Comment by sarampo:
The crop seems a bit too tight, I think it's because of the sun above?
the upper half is too dark, maybe it could be shot from closer / above, so we could see what it is.

Stranded
by phoozt

Comment by Cory:
What the heck is that?? I like the image overall, but... is that a ?? car?

3umbrellas
by phoozt

Comment by tanguera:
Haunting!

3umbrellas
by phoozt

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
An interesting and quirky idea, but the white balance really tosses an unappealing yellow cast on it.