Montreal
by bormic

Comment by fran:
I find the leaves in the foreground too distracting - I guess the idea was the frame the landscape, but I find them too much. it looked like a nice sky though that could have been empahsised more. an interesting skyline nonetheless :)

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by backslash:
Very nicely framed.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by coolhar:
I like the way the foliage in the foreground adds color, or colour

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by kiwiness:
I like the concept here, the natural framing with the trees comes over well, especially bringing in the reds to break the grey cityscape colors.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by pcody:
I somewhat like the foreground. And I know that all the books say you have to have a foreground, but what the books don't say is the foreground should compliment the picture either by framing in a pleasing way or thru repetition of the shape of the body of the picture. The foreground should not be more overpowering than the body of the picture. So using this, the red in the leaves compliment the red in the one building. That is good. The limbs on the side just get in the way and distract from the view.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by Viveca:
great

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by ccjp:
Nice composition, but it is a bit oversharpened for my tastes.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by Dave Gordon:
Nice foreground for the city - it adds a lot of color to an otherwise near monochrome cityscape. The red light at the top of the building near the center picks up the bright red and draws me into the photo.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by bruski:
Personally, I would have liked to see the fore ground sharp as well. But other than that I really like this image.

Montreal
by bormic

Comment by stevenayer:
Visual appeal 2/4, technical 2/3, meeting the challenge 3/3 - 7/10