Pasta
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
Such a simple shot. The diagonal pasta really adds interest and dynamics to this!

Carbs...Just look! Don't touch!
by Patzt

Comment:
Boy, I pity those on the Atkins' Diet. Of course, we on the Weight Watchers Program would have difficulty with this one as well. Great focus. maybe a touch busy -- perhaps you could have isolated one piece and shot it. Otherwise, why don't you send me a piece of it!

Kitchen Vortex
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
The blue, in addition to the texture, really gives this abstract a neat feeling. Great work.

Kitchen Artistry
by DougPaz

Comment:
Beautiful. I love the contrasting colors.

Blind Faucet
by jenarom

Comment:
I love the contrast of the faucet and blinds. The coloring is very attention grabbing. One teeny-weeny nit -- I can see you!

Still Life with Oranges
by boyte1

Comment:
I like the composition of this, and how the fruit gives the eyes a place to rest. Very nicely done.

With Flavour
by Pep Ventosa

Comment:
A very elegant shot of a very simple subject. You have lit this in and astoundingly remarkably and effective way. Good work.

Bouquet
by Alecia

Comment:
This would look super hanging on the wall of a modern kitchen. I really like the bright and contrasting colors. Wonderful.

Old fashioned
by kiwiness

Comment:
I absolutely love this picture, and everything about it -- the focus, the lighting, and coloring. Looks like a shot for Southern Living or Good Housekeeping magazine!

Closed!
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat

COMPOSITION
I really like how the picture "starts" on the lower left, and takes the eyes up the stairs, back to the left, and then over the bridge. It definitely allows the eyes some movement in the picture, without being overly busy or cluttered. Probably because of the way it is colored, though, the sign becomes the main focal point to me, instead of the bridge. It just kinda jumps out at me.
Would it have been possible to crop the pole out some way? It kinda distracts from the overall quality, I think.
Someone below mentioned moving some to the left. If you could have gotten more of the expanse, in addition to the steps, I think that would have been really effective.

TECHNIQUE
The focus and lighting work well together to give this picture an "aged" look, which suits the subject well.

OVERALL EFFECT
Your composition, and use of sepia, really gives the impression of "CLOSED" here to me, os I think you have done a good job. Some minor things in teh general composition may have made it a stronger picture for more of the viewers, however.

Best to you in future challenges.
karmat