Chewy Swirls
by Sonifo

Comment:
I like the richeness of the colors. Also, the angle that you have shot it with, and your composition is also very good. Just a note, and it has nothing to do with your score, but the border seems a bit wide and intrusive to me.

as the worm turns
by falvey

Comment:
Wonderful focus and colors!

Find the Intruder
by Jacko

Comment:
Great work. Took me a second to find it. The lighting is just a touch harsh,but the colors and focus are wonderful.

I am GUMBALL..... I am candy!
by casualguy

Comment:
I love the simplicity of this. The darkness and shadow is very effective, I believe

Licorice Candy
by Swashbuckler

Comment:
Great colors. The lighting seems to be a little harsh, making the white ones almost blow out, but otherwise nicely done.

Licorice L'Amore
by dsidwell

Comment:
Great effect, and a good idea. I find myself wanting to slide the plate to the left just a touch though.

The King of Sugar Mountain
by BigSmiles

Comment:
I lvoe this shot. The focus is perfect, as are the colors. Very nice composition as well. I wouldn't change a thing!! 10

Symmetry In Silver
by Isaac

Comment:
Isaac,
You have chosen a very good subject for "symmetry." It is not a typical symmetrical shot, and that helps to add interest. Also, I like the way it is in the center of a square frame. I think that helps to emphasize the the shape of the tire. I also like that the rubber part is almost completely invisible, making it look like the rim part is suspended or floating in air.

I think something that would have made this better, though, would have been to maybe find a car sitting still so that you could have gotten really close to it. That way you wouldn't have to sample up and it would be a lot clearer. Your exposure and stuff is right on. Good work.

Odds & Ends
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat

(This is the third time I have typed this comment, for various reasons, it keeps getting lost, so if it appears short and choppy, that is why. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact me, and I will elaborate.)

This is simply an awesome shot. The staggering of the two sizes of glasses adds interest, I think, and the different "types" or shapes of glasses really adds a sense of randomness that adds context to the shot for me. It's almost like they are sitting on a bar or counter, waitign to be used. The off-levelness of it is a bit disconcerting, but i see in you comments why that is done that way.
Very well done focus and lighting. I am very impressed that hte reflections are as well focused as the "originals." Also, the light reflections are okay with me. They are glasses. Glasses reflect. If you could have prevented that, I think it would have looked unnatural. Better reflections than fingerprints and smudges.
This is a very elegant shot. I think the black and white works very well, though I think color (either by lights or in post processing) could be used to sit various moods effectively. Nicely done.

karmat

WTC
by lionelm

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat

COMPOSITION
The composition here is strong with the two towers of quarters being the primary item of focus and them being located on the left third. The small stacks also adds to the effect.

TECHNIQUE
While I find the green strip at the bottom a little distracting, I don't think eliminating would serve to help. The focus is fine, but the picture does look a little dark to me. I think some colored lights (blue, etc) shining onto the tower at various points would have made this shot a lot more interesting.

OVERALL EFFECT
I think this is a neat idea, it just needs a little more light to be truly effective. Good work.

Best to you in future challenges.
karmat