Petals
by agwright

Comment:
I really like this shot. the composition of having it "quartered" really adds interest, adn the colors are so rich and pleasing to the eye. Excellent work.

Looking Back
by mbardeen

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat

The quality of this shot is awesome. The exposure seems to be just right, and the focus is right on. It has a "rich" quality to it; the sepia really gives it a vintage feeling as well. I like the vignetting, it makes it feel like I am looking through a telescope or something. I've read through your comments, and really can't think of anything else to say to improve this shot. I found it superb in technique and composition, and it is a creative take on the challenge. Nicely done.

Best to you in future challenges.

photographer in the glass
by thatguy

Comment:
The shot seems a little grainy to me. Was it your ISO setting, or light? I like the strong vertical motion.

Cheers!
by sabal5

Comment:
Nice color contrast.

Smoked Glass!
by Anewbe4u

Comment:
Great capture of the smoke. That is not always easy to do. I think a composition that didn't have the entire glass and lid in it would be more effective. Arrange them differently, then crop or frame the top of the glass.

Imprisoned for light
by autumngirl786

Comment:
I think getting closer, and not cropping so much would make this a much better shot.

italian soda
by jblharshaw

Comment:
At first, I gave this a rather low score, but upon second looks, I like the detail you have captured. I don't think I like the green color too well though, but to each his own.

Simple.
by Geocide

Comment:
I think lowering the subject in the frame would have added much more interest to the overall shot.

Painted Glass
by CountryGirl03

Comment:
To really add some interest to this shot, I think it may have been better to get much closer and capture just the corner with the paint. Also, it seems a bit over exposed, so maybe waitiing until a different time of day would have help.

"COLBALT"
by Denise Catania

Comment:
I really like the shade of blue in this, and it makes for an interesting abstract. It just doesn't appeal to me, though, as a photograph, as I don't see anything other than the blue, and the shapes, to be the object of focus.