VW
by jonpink

Comment:
Nice panning... I like the composition you chose here as well... = 6

Chasing the wind
by divernick

Comment:
This photo has some good potential. The noise and odd color seems a bit strange to me... somewhat abstract. = 4

Zooom!
by scrum8

Comment:
The subtle motion blur here is good. The photo seems to lack context though. Is she walking, running, riding a bike? The background choice doens't really support the subject well either. = 3

Country Walking Magazine
by jonpink

Comment:
Jon, this was one of my favorite photos in the challenge, but I never got around to commenting on much this week. This is an excellent photo. I love the angry feel of the clouds. The color here is nice but I'm wondering if you have experimented with a slightly contrasty and grainy b/w feel for this one...

Nice work :)

Ducks Unlimited
by nsoroma79

Comment:
Hi Lorrie...

I was just reading your comment about the light not being good because it was overcast. I found that quite interesting because I do a lot of duck/geese/waterfowl photos and I generally prefer overcast skies to direct sunlight for them. I find my good exposures come a lot easier in even soft light rather than harsh sun. This particular image could have had some rough shadows underneath or on either side with direct sun... I just thought I would toss that in here and see how u felt about it. :)

John Setzler

My Son In Motion
by Mona

Comment:
This looks like a pretty good stopped motion shot :) Maybe some spool walking would create a more impactive photo overall also... = 3

Carrera GT
by Homunculus

Comment:
This photo has some nice blur effect. The problem is that the wheel blur should be in conjunction with the blur of the background in a pan shot like this :) The lack of surface also creates a tad of undue tension... = 5

Butterfly landing (no added blur in PS)
by ccraft

Comment:
The wing motion here is nice. The title costs you about 3 points. = 2

blurry poppy
by thomkat

Comment:
This simply feels out of focus rather than motion blurred. The background is very distracting and 'busy' and doesn't support your subject very well. = 2

Colours
by train

Comment:
This photo feels more out of focus than motion blurred to me. I'm not sure I really understand the motion theme of the presentation. I assume the CDs are falling. This photo is difficult for me to grasp your idea and intent. = 3