Mating Dance?
by photom

Comment:
Beautiful shot :) The silhouettes are perfect and it does appear that the two birds are 'communicating' in this image. The timing of this shot is perfect...

Mechanical Worms of Brooklyn
by the-O-ster

Comment:
This is a great urban/industrial mood... very lending to a strong black and white image... excellent composition.

Crypt
by Luca66

Comment:
Very nice image... I love the light interaction in the entire scene. I'm not sure how much impact the door frame on the sides is adding though... excellent work :)

a Room with a view
by Nazgul

Comment:
Excellent work... I like a photo that generates some 'tension' and this one does that nicely by making me wonder what is visible outside the window. The darkness of the image lead me to believe that whatever is being viewed is not good or 'evil' in some way... great shot :) = 10

Dune
by t_online

Comment:
Very nice work :)

Colourful Windpower after the Rain
by simbamba

Comment:
This is a great shot... the horizon is tilted just enought that it's visible though... great work :)

The Strength of Photography
by Zap228

Comment:
The strength of focus would be helpful :)

Power of One: Rise Above the Rest
by paganini

Comment:
beautiful... = 10

Mountain Light
by dsidwell

Comment:
David,

Sorry I didn't get around to commenting on this during the challenge. It was one of quite a few tens I gave. Stunning work as usual :)

An oldie but a goodie!
by aKiwi

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club...

Hi aKiwi...

This image seems to meet the challenge well and it received a good average score in the end. Critique on this one is a bit difficult. I can't say that I would change anything about it. It appears that you achieved your objective. There is nothing that could be added or removed that would make a significant change in the presentation.

Now, from a personal standpoint...

What WAS your objective with this photo? Is it a design for the sole purpose of the challenge? What does the image say to you? What does it say about you? Is there emotional value here? Is music a part of your personality?

Keep up the good work :)

John Setzler