Fire And Ice
by Firstrich1

Comment:
great showing... i had hoped to see a ribbon on this one :)

Greenbriar
by pitsaman

Comment:
beautiful shot :)

Ooooooh !!!
by bmarquez

Comment:
I love this shot... I have been holding off on a comment because I have been spending a lot of time looking at it. The round faces definitely bring you into the challenge theme very easily. The facial expression begs me to wonder what they are looking at... that being said, this makes a great 'unanswered questions' photo too :) Excellent composition and great idea for the challenge :) = 10

Sphere
by Alecia

Comment:
great work with the color and light on this photo... it's very.. umm... 'scab-esque' :) The texture on the left side of the sphere seems to be maybe a tad 'oversharp' but I'm not entirely sure of that... excellent work :)

Japan's Obsession
by joannadiva

Comment:
This is a really neat photo for sure... The similarity to the Japanese flag and the tie in with the obsession with golf there is a really unique and appealing thought for this photograph. The only area for improvement I can see in this photo would be an attempt to even out the lighting on the background and get it as close to white as possible for even more impact. Great shot...

Convex Portal
by Tarbini

Comment:
I have been waiting several days to post a comment on this photo... It's my favorite photo of the challenge and I can't really put my finger on WHY. I believe it's in the simplicity of the image. The monochromatic theme... the square frame with the abstract distortion in the mirror. All I can say is 'excellent work' :) = 10

Circle Star Salute
by Mecca

Comment:
i can't say much about this shot other than 'phenomenal'. I love the motion here and you captured it at the perfect time it seems. That motion seems to create a beautiful sense of surrealism and 'ghostliness' in this photo... great shot and one of my favs this week :) = 10

Still Round
by Toddh

Comment:
This is gorgeous... I think you nailed the exposure on this shot.. i can still see detail inside the bowl. The simplicity of the subject in this photo is definitely one of the strong points of the shot... great work.. = 10

golf ball
by jimmyn4

Comment:
The concept behind this photo is quite strong and the idea is good. I don't traditionally thing of golf balls as having a yellow tint. This is probalby cause by white balance issues and could be corrected rather easily also. This image should probably also be sharp instead of out of focus. I can't see how the choice to make this soft focus is really helping the image.

Be gentle -- first sub
by sn4psh07

Comment:
Interesting photo and poor title. "Pandering" in the title is sure to get you in trouble. I think this is the beginning of a good photo. The lighting isn't working.. looks like an on cam flash probably. Natural lighting may not have been possible, and if so, maybe a different subject choice would have worked out better for you...